Good price or no...paint and shave

Ok, I'm starting to look for a painter, etc, and my parents suggested checking with the people who fixed my sisters Eclipse when she wrecked it, so..I did.
I went by, and they were pretty cool, but I've got NO idea what stuff like this should cost. They offer a lifetime warranty on their work, which is good, so here's what I was told...

I've got a dent on my front fender (decent sized one), and two smaller indentations. To pull those and "make new", shave the antenna on the opposite fender, shave the logo on the grill shell, install, align and prep new bumper and hood, then paint it all and fade it in is $1,600.
The whole front clip would be painted (both fenders, hood,bumper), and he said he'd knock $200 off if I did it all at once (total was actually just a tad over 1800, then the 200 off got me to the 1600).

Does that sound reasonable?

I'm still undecided if I want a new hood and whether or not I should shave the antenna and grill shell, but I'm definately gonna get a new bumper cover, and have the one fender fixed, so I figured I'd look into getting the rest done. I'm gonna check some other shops around here, just figured I'd get your opinions on the matter, as many of you have had some sort of body work done.